Category: Israel/Palestine

It will always be a mistake as long as Israel is investigating itself. It's just like the police policing themselves. It's never intentional. 

From Greg Fallis:

Remember Jennifer and James Crumbley? Sure you do. They're Ethan's parents. You know, Ethan Crumbly? Oh, c'mon…the 15-year-old kid who shot and killed four of his classmates at Oxford High School in Michigan. Ring a bell? The murders happened back in 2021, but a month ago Jennifer Crumbley was found guilty of involuntary manslaughter because she 1) failed to get Ethan the mental health care he needed, and 2) made it possible for him to have access to both a handgun and ammunition.

Here's the thing: the US are Jennifer and James Crumbley. The Israeli government is Ethan. And the thirty thousand dead men, women, and children in Gaza? They're the victims of an international school shooting.

Just like Ethan's parents, the US (and the world) has known for a long time that the government of Israel has been a threat to the daily existence of Palestinians. We've known about the government's support of illegal settlements in the West Bank, we've known about their harsh policies toward Gaza. And yeah, like Ethan, some groups of Palestinians have made matters worse because of their behavior. But the fact remains, the US has been aware of the dangerous and destructive behavior of Israel. And like Ethan's parents, we've not only ignored the abuse and the risk, we've deliberately enabled it by supplying the Israeli government with all manner of weaponry.

And hey, we're still doing that. Thirty thousand plus dead Gazan — a large proportion of which are children — and we continue to hand them weapons. Yes, we're saying, "Please use these weapons responsibly" but that's like buying your 15-year-old mentally ill child a handgun, helping him load it, and asking him not to kill his classmates.

Jennifer Crumbly has been found guilty for making it possible for her son to kill other kids. Her husband's trial will be held in the near future; he'll likely be found guilty as well. In any rational, responsible World Criminal Court, the US will…well, you can figure it out.

I'm sure Ethan's parents feel horrible about what happened. I'm sure they wish they'd acted before it was too late. I'm sure they just didn't realize how their parental failure would harm others. I'm sure they had no idea how much it would harm Ethan and themselves. I'm sure that if they'd been present during the shooting, they'd have at least tried to take Ethan's 9mm handgun and stopped the killing.

The US could do that. We could just stop providing the Israeli government with the weapons its using to commit genocide against the Palestinian people. It's far too late, of course, but too late is better than never. We could stop giving Israel weaponry; it would be the moral equivalent of taking away Ethan's handgun after he's shot a few classmates. There are already too many bodies on the international schoolroom floor; nothing is going to change that. But we could try to prevent more bodies from stacking up.

We could do that. But we won't.